August 24, 2010
A Memo to the MSM on Imam Rauf - From an Actual Moderate MuslimTopics: Political News and commentaries, Understanding Islam
Abdur-Rahman Muhammad, an African American Muslim convert of nearly a quarter century, believes he's earned the right to weigh in on the bitter controversy surrounding the proposed mosque at Ground Zero, and has written a memo to the imam-supporting MSM.
As I write, nearly two thousand protesters are gathered outside the location of the future mosque -- some having stood in the rain for hours -- providing a clear indication that the campaign to stop this project is intensifying. The pollsters tell us that nearly 70 percent of all Americans oppose the structure, yet its sponsors say the edifice will somehow promote "interfaith dialogue" and "mutual understanding." They must certainly realize at this stage in the process that the mosque will do no such thing, but will instead act as a permanent provocation to a huge segment of Americans who deem it completely inappropriate -- if not outright sacrilege.Continue reading ...
Let us remember that the project organizers themselves created this controversy by announcing that the groundbreaking would take place on the ten-year anniversary of the attack, and that the exact site was selected because of its proximity to Ground Zero. Given that fact, the current media meme that this is not a "Ground Zero mosque" is dishonest spin.
Even more dishonest -- and dangerous to this country -- is the outrageously biased work in Time, the New York Times, the Washington Post, and Newsweek, and on NPR, PBS, MSNBC and CNN that has consistently portrayed popular opposition to this mosque and several other mosques around the country as evidence of bigotry and so-called "Islamophobia." This is mass libel by these media institutions.
The mainstream media has deliberately ignored the fact that there is legitimate basis for fear of mosques -- as it is a demonstrable fact that mosques and Muslims have been disproportionately connected to terrorism in this country and around the world, a fact that the media won't report. Moreover, in the examples of opposition to specific mosques chosen by the media as evidence of popular "bigotry," the media has selectively ignored the openly available evidence showing unambiguously that these mosques or their officials are connected to or supportive of the radical Muslim Brotherhood (the parent of al-Qaeda), Hamas, and other radical Islamic fundamentalist organizations.
Why have these media institutions not investigated these ties? Why does the media investigate American charities that support settlements in the West Bank, but refuse to investigate the militant and terrorist ties to mosques and Islamic groups here at home?
The imam heading up this $100 million project, Faisal Abdul Rauf, enjoys the full support of the sympathizing left-leaning media, and together they have attempted to frame this fight as a First Amendment issue. They've worked to cast the opponents of the project -- including the 9/11 families -- as bigots bent on denying "peaceful Muslims" the "right" to build a facility on their own property. All of this is sheer nonsense, because as many commentators already noted this week, the right to build the mosque was never in question -- only the appropriateness of putting it near Ground Zero. It is simply not possible, and indeed quite dishonest, to characterize 70 percent of the population as bigots and "Islamophobes," despite what the media would have us believe.
As an American Muslim, I can say with confidence that most folks have no desire to trample our First Amendment rights, and have said so repeatedly. It is not even entirely clear to me that, were the Muslim developers of the mosque genuinely moderate, it would be so bitterly opposed. But then again, they probably would never have proposed such a thing in the first place.
But how can anyone believe that Imam Faisal Abdul Rauf and his followers are moderates when they very deliberately refuse to condemn Hamas, a sworn enemy of this country and a major center of terror in the world? When asked directly to repudiate the group, all he could say was "I am not a politician."
This is typical of the double-speak and evasive tactics employed by the prominent Muslim groups in America, an unmistakable red flag that something is wrong here.
Abdur-Rahman Muhammad is not the only Muslim speaking out against the GZ mosque. As we've previously posted, Neda Bolourchi, a Muslim victim of 9/11, also had a message for the supporters of the Ground Zero Mosque: "Build your ideological monument somewhere else, far from her mother's grave. She expressed fears that "It would become a symbol of victory for militant Muslims around the world." and that "it will cultivate a fundamentalist version of the Muslim faith, embracing those who share such beliefs and hating those who do not." Raheel Raza and Tarek Fatah spoke out in the Ottawa Citizen and expressed similar concerns, saying that it's a "Deliberate Bad-Faith Provocation."
And they're not alone in their condemnation of the imam and the location of the mosque. There are many other Muslims speaking out as well. Take for example Dr. M. Zuhdi Jasser, president of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy and a former US Navy lieutenant commander, who wrote in the NY Post:
The World Trade Center site represents Ground Zero in America's war against radical Islamists who seek to destroy the American way of life. It is not ground zero of a cultural exchange.Unfortunately, President Obama, Mayor Michael Blumberg, and the MSM just aren't listening.
We American Muslims cannot merely passively avoid Islamists like the Muslim Brotherhood and its offshoots. We need to ask ourselves: Are we Americans who happen to be Muslim or Muslims blindly demanding to be American?
American Muslims will be better served if this project is built further away from Ground Zero and focuses on leading a reform effort. If we help build anything at the WTC site itself, it should be timeless memorials to all those who lost their lives on 9/11 -- memorials blind to faith, race, creed or national origin.
Posted by Richard at August 24, 2010 11:52 AM
Articles Related to Political News and commentaries, Understanding Islam: