June 12, 2010
More Dhimitude: YouTube pulls "We Con the World" videoTopics: Follies of the Mainstream Media, Middle East News and Perspectives, Political News and commentaries, Understanding Islam
We just finished posting about PayPal's submission to Islamist pressure by demsnding conservative blogger Pamela Geller remove the PayPal buttons at her site because they consider her blog a "hate site." Now we learn that YouTube has removed most versions of Latma's viral hit parody song We Con the World.
Caroline Glick explains:
As Israel went offline for the Jewish sabbath, YouTube removed most versions of Latma's hit parody song We Con the World. If you try to access the song on YouTube you receive the notification:Read more here ...
This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Warner/ Chappell Music, Inc.
Copyright experts we advised with before posting the song told us in no uncertain terms that we were within our rights to use the song because we did so in accordance with the Fair Use Doctrine. The Fair Use Doctrine, copied and pasted below from the US Copyright Office stipulates that it is legal and permissible to use copyrighted material under the fair use doctrine for purposes of parody.
Copyright attorneys also warned us that given our clearly lawful use of the song We are the World, if anyone wished to silence our voices, they wouldn't target us. Instead they would target YouTube. It is YouTube's standard practice to remove any material that they receive even the flimsiest threat for because the company wishes to avoid all litigation.
At the same time, this is not YouTube's first move to silence Israeli voices. During Operation Cast Lead, the IDF Spokesman's Unit established a YouTube channel and began posting combat footage on its channel to bypass the anti-Israel media and go directly to news consumers.
Shortly after the IDF channel began making waves, YouTube - which is owned by Google - removed IDF videos from the website. After the move evoked a storm of protest, YouTube restored them but flagged the videos in the same manner it flags pornography. People trying to access the videos received a screen saying, "This video or group may contain content that is inappropriate for some users, as flagged by YouTube's user community. To view this video or group please verify that you are 18 or older by singing in and signing up."
Here's a link to the write-up of the YouTube move.
If YouTube didn't already have a track record for censoring pro-Israel material, I would say that despite the obviously frivolous and unsubstantiated nature of the copyright claim against We Con the World, the company was simply erring on the side of caution.
The fact that more than 3 million people have already seen the video and that it has been written up in major newspapers and featured on major television networks around the world since we first posted it last Thursday night however causes me to fear that something else is going on here.
Despite these obstacles, we at Latma have no intention of crying Uncle. By tomorrow, we will repost our song on blogs throughout the world. If you already downloaded the song, please post it on your website. If not, I will post a non-youtube version on my site tomorrow with instructions from my webmaster about how to download it.
Moreover, stay tuned for our next video next Thursday night.
In a demonstration that it's futilite to attempt to silence people in today's open-source world, Ed Morrissey has uploaded the video to his Eyeblast account. It can be viewed here:
As Ed notes in his post, hopefully Eyeblast might prove a little more stalwart than YouTube when it comes to supporting the rights of content producers. Although the video still exists in at least one place at YouTube (at least for the moment), his posting allows us to still see the video just in case YouTube sniffs it out.
Posted by Richard at June 12, 2010 10:09 PM
Articles Related to Follies of the Mainstream Media, Middle East News and Perspectives, Political News and commentaries, Understanding Islam:
- More Dhimitude: YouTube pulls "We Con the World" video - Jun 12, 2010