May 27, 2010
Obama gave Brazil green light for Iran dealTopics: Political News and commentaries
In what amounts to perhaps the most startling example of the Obama administration's "appalling lack of skill in diplomacy" exemplified by its amateurish efforts to halt Iran's nuclear program, it turns out that Obama gave the green light to President Luiz Incio Lula da Silva to pursue an agreement in which Iran would transfer part of its stockpile of enriched uranium to Turkey.
Jonathan Tobin writes:
This startling piece of news was buried toward the bottom of a New York Times report on the latest developments in Iranian diplomacy. The article devoted most of its space to new tensions between Tehran and Moscow.Read more ...
The Iran/Brazil/Turkey deal was a blatant Iranian attempt to derail faltering American efforts to build an international coalition that supports sanctions against Tehran to pressure the Iranians to give up their nuclear ambitions. It would also not prevent the Iranians from continuing to amass material to build a bomb. This diplomatic freelancing on the part of both Brazil and Turkey was widely seen as a slap in the face to Obama at just the moment that the American president had started to cobble together enough support for a weak sanctions package.
But although both the Brazilians and the Turks deserve the opprobrium that has been heaped upon them for allowing Iran's tyrannical Islamist regime to use them to divert attention away from sanctions efforts, it must be conceded that what they have done isn't any more foolish than a similar deal that the United States, itself, tried to make with Iran last fall. That disaster, which came after several months of unsuccessful attempts at engagement with Tehran, fell through after the Iranians embarrassed the administration by reneging on an agreement to transfer uranium. Obama and his foreign-policy team seemingly learned their lesson after this fiasco and finally began to talk about sanctions. To gain tepid Russian support for sanctions, the Obama administration has had to water down its proposals to a point where it is clear that little damage will be done to Iran. But after having labored so hard to achieve so little, Washington was clearly outraged by being outflanked by Brazil and Turkey's untimely intervention earlier this month.
But if the mere fact of this new deal wasn't enough to undermine international support for sanctions, the revelation that Brazil acted with the express written permission of Obama must be seen as a catastrophe for international efforts to restrain Tehran. Why should anyone take American rhetoric about stopping Iran seriously if Obama is now understood to have spent the last months pushing for sanctions in public while privately encouraging third parties who are trying to appease the Iranians?
Charles Krauthammer provides a perspective on the effects of the Brazil/turkey/iran deal:
It is perfectly obvious that Iran's latest uranium maneuver, brokered by Brazil and Turkey, is a ruse. Iran retains more than enough enriched uranium to make a bomb. And it continues enriching at an accelerated pace and to a greater purity (20 percent). Which is why the French foreign ministry immediately declared that the trumpeted temporary shipping of some Iranian uranium to Turkey will do nothing to halt Iran's nuclear program.In other words, the Obama administration has once again shown its incompetence in foreign policy and taken us yet another step toward a nuclear Iran.
It will, however, make meaningful sanctions more difficult. America's proposed Security Council resolution is already laughably weak -- no blacklisting of Iran's central bank, no sanctions against Iran's oil and gas industry, no nonconsensual inspections on the high seas. Yet Turkey and Brazil -- both current members of the Security Council -- are so opposed to sanctions that they will not even discuss the resolution. And China will now have a new excuse to weaken it further.
But the deeper meaning of the uranium-export stunt is the brazenness with which Brazil and Turkey gave cover to the mullahs' nuclear ambitions and deliberately undermined U.S. efforts to curb Iran's program.
The real news is that already notorious photo: the president of Brazil, our largest ally in Latin America, and the prime minister of Turkey, for more than half a century the Muslim anchor of NATO, raising hands together with Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the most virulently anti-American leader in the world.
That picture -- a defiant, triumphant take-that-Uncle-Sam -- is a crushing verdict on the Obama foreign policy. It demonstrates how rising powers, traditional American allies, having watched this administration in action, have decided that there's no cost in lining up with America's enemies and no profit in lining up with a U.S. president given to apologies and appeasement.
[...] Given Obama's policies and principles, Turkey and Brazil are acting rationally. Why not give cover to Ahmadinejad and his nuclear ambitions? As the U.S. retreats in the face of Iran, China, Russia and Venezuela, why not hedge your bets? There's nothing to fear from Obama, and everything to gain by ingratiating yourself with America's rising adversaries. After all, they actually believe in helping one's friends and punishing one's enemies. (Emphasis added)
Posted by Richard at May 27, 2010 11:25 AM
Articles Related to Political News and commentaries:
- Obama gave Brazil green light for Iran deal - May 27, 2010