June 8, 2007
Bad Immigration Think 101: For This They Were Willing To Sell Out Their Constituency?Topics: Immigration and Border Issues
In a striking defeat for the Open Borders Lobby, the sweeping immigration overhaul endorsed by President Bush crumbled in the Senate on Thursday night, leaving the future of one of the administration's chief domestic priorities in serious doubt. Senate bill S. 1348 failed to get the needed Cloture votes two twice yesterday, causing Senator Harry Reid to pull the bill from the floor. Supporters of cutting off debate got only 45 of the 60 votes they needed; 50 senators opposed the cutoff (38 Republicans, 11 Democrats and one independent voted not to shut off debate). That's the good news.
But why did 7 Republicans support it ?
John Hawkins' at Right Wing News asked his "personal inside source" in the Senate if his boss has been hearing from his constituents on this bill and what the for and against ratio was. He said that they have received thousands and thousands of calls and the ratio was something like 95%-98% against the bill. John then asked his source why he thought so many Republicans had been supporting such an incredibly unpopular bill. He gave three reasons that in my mind, are the best reasons I can think of for making sure the senator that exercised such reasoning is voted the hell out of office.
So I ask you, are any of these reasons worth supporting such an incredibly unpopular bill that is clearly, at least in the minds of conservatives, against the interests of the country?
... the "Rovian School of thought," which says passing this bill would capture the Hispanic vote for the GOP for decades to come.I didn't think so either ....
... heavily influenced by business groups that want cheap labor no matter what the cost is for the rest of the country.
... willing to sign onto a terrible bill just so they could say they were part of a big reform that had bipartisan support.
John Hawkins has more on The Inside Story Of How The Senate Immigration Bill Died.
Posted by Richard at June 8, 2007 1:00 PM
The whole "businesses want cheap labor" argumetn holds no water. think about it, businesses are currently enjoying the best of all possible circumstances. they can get them to work cheap, under the table, they don't have to pay insurance or even the Minimum Wage. If they are made legal, suddenly they no longer are attractive employees, they have to pay income tax, and SS, and insurance, and Workmen's Comp. All the stuff that made their former situation advantageous. Businesses should be FIGHTING amnesty, but they are not. which is telling me that there is something I'm not seeing.
Posted by: Rorschach at June 11, 2007 12:04 AM
Articles Related to Immigration and Border Issues:
- Bad Immigration Think 101: For This They Were Willing To Sell Out Their Constituency? - Jun 08, 2007