« Bush Seeks Ban On Bottom Trawling | Main
October 04, 2006
Islamic Scholar Says Koran Has Flaws - Needs To Be Reinterpreted For Today
Topics: Understanding Islam
[Muslim minds 'closed': Ameer Ali, doctor of economics at Murdoch University in Perth, says the Koran must not be read literally but reinterpreted for today. Picture: Colin Murty]
Almost on cue from our earlier post this morning, "Muslim on Muslim Violence: What Drives It? (And Where Is It Taking Us)," and from our numerous calls for someone of authority in the Muslim world to step forward and demand
reform in Islam, and reinterpret the Koran for the modern world, along comes such a person. I just came across this in yesterday's The Australian (via Jihad Watch). Ameer Ali, a leading advisor on Islam and chairman of John Howard's Muslim advisory board, condemns Muslims who "blindly" follow their faith and fail to question the veracity of the Koran, saying that even Mohammed had "flaws". He warns that Islamists will continue to breed jihadis unless the Koran is "reinterpreted" for today's society:
[...] A LEADING adviser on Islam, Ameer Ali, has attacked Muslims who "blindly" follow their faith and fail to question the veracity of the Koran, saying that even Mohammed had "flaws".The chairman of John Howard's Muslim advisory board yesterday warned that Islamists would continue to breed jihadis unless the Koran was "reinterpreted" for today's society.
He also said mosques were increasingly being used by imams to deliver sermons that were not open to discussion.
Dr Ali said the majority of Muslim clerics had for centuries imposed a "literalist" teaching of Islam, telling their followers that deviating from the written message would ultimately lead to their admission into hell.
"The times are changing and with the change of times, you also have to reinterpret the Koran," he told The Australian.
"Because if you believe that it's a book for all the times and all the nations, then that book must be yielding new meanings.Robert Spencer comments that a retreat from this literalism that Ali speaks of is likely the only hope for the creation of a real and lasting moderate form of Islam."There are verses about slavery, and the Koran says you must be kind to the slaves. So are the Muslims saying we must have slavery to be kind?
"The jihadists are interpreting the Koran literally and that's the problem ... Popular Muslims, because of their lack of knowledge about religion, are vulnerable to these sort of teachings."
... notably, although not universally, in central Asia, Eastern Europe, and West Africa, jihad supremacism largely lay dormant and even dropped out of the Muslim consciousness. But simply to point out that that happened is not enough anymore, precisely because Wahhabi and Iranian Shi'ite recruiters are going into those countries and using chapter and verse of Qur'an and Sunnah to teach their Islam to these cultural Muslims. So for those cultural Muslims, and for any true moderates, it's no longer possible simply to ignore those jihad verses. They have to be explicitly rejected, and a non-literalist Islam constructed.There can be no doubt in the minds of literally everyone reading this, Ameer Ali is going to be attacked for his words, and may even receive death threats - many from so-called moderate Muslims that read and take the Koran, literally.But also because of the mainstream character of literalism within Islam, this will be very, very difficult. Watch and see, for example, what kind of reception Ameer Ali's words get.
Posted by Richard at October 4, 2006 09:38 AM
Articles Related to Understanding Islam:
- Religious Freedom In Iran: Discrimination, Forced Mass Conversions - Oct 04, 2006
- Muslim on Muslim Violence: What Drives It? (And Where Is It Taking Us) - Oct 04, 2006
- 'Another Ramadan Muslim holy day, another round of Muslim-on-Muslim killings' - Oct 03, 2006
- Bobble Head Mohammad - It's Simply Free Speech - Oct 02, 2006
- Paraphrasing Isaiah: "No Peace for Islamists' - 'Religion of Perpetual Rage,' saith the Lord!" - Oct 02, 2006
- On 'Muslims' Complicity With Violence' - Sep 28, 2006
- CAIR Goes After Michigan Congressman (Updated) - Sep 28, 2006
- It's A 'Holy Month' - Time To Riot - Sep 27, 2006
- Commentary On Islam, From Churchill's 'The River War (1899)' - Sep 26, 2006
- When Will We Know Reform Has Reached The Muslim World? - Sep 26, 2006
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Comments
Subject: ecumenical councilTo All:
The Muslim are in dire need of an ecumenical council in order to keep up with the times. It will be difficult to bring the Koran from the 7th Century to the 21st Century, but it will be worth their effort ... if they intend to continue to thrive on this planet.
With Aloha,
# Posted by harry at 10/04/2006 02:08 pm - reply- forum
I have been following this story on Robert Spencer's Jihad Watch site. FYI another Muslim has stated that Ameer Ali is to be treated as though he is ostracized over his comments.Also, this is the same man who wanted Hezbollah to be taken off the terrorist list claiming that they are freedom fighters.
There is a real need for reform within Islam but there are still too few that will make the effort to look inwardly and then at the world around themselves to see the poor image that Islam has maintained because of the violence.
So long as they deny that Mohammed was a very violent man, or that violent Jihad is advocated in the Koran, then there cannot be any move forward.
As far as Ameer Ali is concerned, I doubt that there will be too many who will listen to him.
# Posted by Maggie at 10/04/2006 10:12 pm - reply- forum
Subject: LEADING adviser?Unfrortunatly, this Ameer Ali guy is a lightweight in the world of Islamic scholarship.
A single scholar can do little; a real debate is needed, but there is too much oil fueling the fire of hate. Litterally.
Islam is now the hostage of people who are pursuing their own demagogic agendas.
# Posted by Jeha at 10/07/2006 07:58 pm - reply- forum
