Arab op-ed: Pope's Remarks May Lead To War :: Understanding Islam

« "Difficult to Find Good News in Iraq This Week" Says Partisan Pundit John Roberts at CNN! | Main

September 17, 2006

Arab op-ed: Pope's Remarks May Lead To War

... Pointing to the unreasonableness and irrationality of violence in the name of God and the unreasonableness of spreading faith by the sword, so offends Muslim "sensitivities" that it can "lead to war" ? Does this not confirm the Pope's point for him?

As we wrote in our piece on September 15, "From Cartoon Jihad To Pope Jihad: Religion Of Perpetual Outrage Is Again - Outraged," the entire world is now aware of Pope Benedict's speech at the University of Regensburg in which he quoted criticism of Islam and the Prophet Mohammed by 14th century Byzantine Emperor Manuel II Palaeologus, who wrote that everything Mohammed brought was evil and inhuman, "such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached". Now we are hearing commentary from the Muslim world such as that of Hani Pahas, who in the London-based Arabic-language daily newspaper Al-Hayat has written that "the pope's comments may lead to war; we fear that the pope's statements may lead to a war that we, Muslims and Christians alike, are trying to prevent through dialogue between East and West." If this seems bizarre and irrational to you, it should.

We pointed out at the time that although the Pope's quote was perhaps not very big on tact, in his defense, spreading faith by the sword is indeed evil and inhuman, and unreasonable. And, as the Pope said in his speech - referring to the argument of Byzantine emperor Manuel II Paleologus':

... "the decisive statement in this argument against violent conversion is this: Not to act in accordance with reason is contrary to God's nature. The editor, Theodore Khoury, observes: For the emperor, as a Byzantine shaped by Greek philosophy, this statement is self-evident (as it should be to any rational and reasonable human being). But for Muslim teaching, God is absolutely transcendent. His will is not bound up with any of our categories, even that of rationality (as is so powerfully verified by the irrationality and lack of proportionality of the Muslim response to the Pope's quote of Emperor Manuel II). Here Khoury quotes a work of the noted French Islamist R. Arnaldez, who points out that Ibn Hazn went so far as to state that God is not bound even by his own word, and that nothing would oblige him to reveal the truth to us. Were it God's will, we would even have to practice idolatry.

Not unexpectedly, religious leaders throughout the Muslim world, including Iran, are slamming the pope. The spiritual leader of Lebanon's Sunnis, the Grand Mufti Sheik Mohammed Rashid Kabbani, said the pope's remarks emanated either from "Ignorance and lack of knowledge or were deliberately intended to distort Islam."

However, anyone looking at the perpetual outrage and constant state of ready-reaction that we've all witnessed in the Muslim world, completely rebuts the argument of Muslim leaders such as Sheik Mohammed Rashid Kabbani, especially when he makes comments like: "Reason is the substance of Islam and its teachings ... Islam prohibited violence in human life, and that anyone who wants the truth (about Islam) must take it from Islam's holy book, the Koran, rather than from a dialogue or excerpts." After all, it is the Koran that is quoted word for word by the Muslim clerics around the world now inflaming their followers to follow violent jihad, conversion by the sword, suicide bombings of innocent "infidels", shooting nuns in the back who work in hospitals, kidnappings, beheadings, ad nauseam.

If remarks by the Pope can be so misinterpreted as to "offend Muslim sensitivities", perhaps much of the Muslim world is far too sensitive because their positions relative to faith without reason, violence in the name of God, violence in the name of their religion, conversion by the sword, and other such examples of unreasonableness, is in fact - unreasonable?

My personal opinion is that there is indeed a Muslim majority that believes as the Grand Mufti Sheik Mohammed Rashid Kabbani suggests, that Islam prohibits violence, includes reason, and that violent jihad and forced conversion is wrong. However, unless these "rational and reasonable" Muslims speak out more strongly than their radical brethren, the view of Islam by the non-Muslim world will continue to be one of unreasonable, irrational, violence. For now, all we are seeing from the Muslim world, every single hour of every single day, is violence and one outrage after another. If one is so sensitive about their faith and remain in a constant state of anxiety and anger, one would think that sooner or later a rational and reasonable person would act to reform and modernize their faith, or leave it. To do otherwise is, irrational.

Posted by Richard at September 17, 2006 08:05 AM

Articles Related to Understanding Islam:

On The Unreasonableness Of Muslim Fury - And The Reasonableness Of Non-Muslim Anger And Disgust With Muslim Outrage - Sep 16, 2006
Opinion: 'The Awesome Freedom to Choose' - Sep 16, 2006
Churches may be burning, but Kudos to the Pope! - Sep 16, 2006
Pope Rage on the Internet; Jihadists Threaten And Insult Pope - Sep 16, 2006
Expert Says Pope Struck A Cord With Muslims - Sep 16, 2006
Are Some Muslims 'Offended by an Inconvenient Truth' ? - Sep 16, 2006
More Perpetual Outrage: 'Out of the Mosque, Into the Street' - Sep 16, 2006
From Cartoon Jihad To Pope Jihad: Religion Of Perpetual Outrage Is Again - Outraged - Sep 15, 2006
"Faith, Reason & The University": Pope Benedict's Speech At The University of Regensburg - Sep 15, 2006
Muslim World Reacts Violently To Pope Saying Jihad Is Violent - Sep 15, 2006

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Arab op-ed: Pope's Remarks May Lead To War:

» Arab op-ed: Pope's Remarks May Lead To War from Freedoms Zone
The recent remarks made by Pope Benedict XVI on Islam are threatening to ignite the entire Muslim world. [Read More]

Tracked on September 17, 2006 09:19 AM

Comments

Subject: "Free Will...."
The decisive point in the Pope's argument against violent conversion is self-evident: It's a violation of our God-given "Free Will"!

We have been given by the Deity, as I quoted from Professor Eiseley previously, the "awesome freedom to choose"! Neither faith, nor love, can be imposed by the edge of a sword, and be genuine!

God wants us to believe in Him, love and honor Him, out of our own "Free Will"! Otherwise, wouldn't He just have "imposed" "Salvation" upon us wether we wanted it or not?!?!

All that compelling people with the sword, by force and intimidation, to bow their foreheads to the floor in "submission" five times a day, is to waft the fragance of many unwashed arses in the wind! Just think what an odorous "incense" to God that must be wafting out of the Mosques up to heaven!!!

Althor :D

# Posted by Althor at 09/17/2006 03:40 pm - reply- forum

It's a shame that so many devout moderate and truly peaceful Muslims are unable, afraid to, or refuse to - condemn terrorism, violence, and forced conversions. The world would be a much more peaceful place if Islamic violence and perpetual outrage from the vocal angry side of Islam was silenced by an uproar by the up until now largely silent and inactive "moderate" Muslims.

# Posted by Richard at 09/17/2006 08:26 pm - reply- forum

Subject: Don't Tempt Us!
Richard:

I do not have a problem finishing what the crusades commenced nearly a millennium ago. The new crusaders will be better prepared than the masses that poured into Constantinople. And, this time, we can do the job right. There exists no military genius like Saladin to stop us. All we need do is lower our Christian morals a bit, and the religion of violence will come face-to-face with real violence.

The Pope should not back down or make apologies. He should just ask us to take up the cross. I suspect that there exists a few Christians out there in need of salvation.

My message to Islam is don't tempt us.

With Aloha,

# Posted by harry at 09/18/2006 09:06 am - reply- forum

Harry,
The irony is that moderate Muslims, and there are in fact some, are as deeply affected as non-Musims are, and could be very helpful in preventing what is, at this point, the near-inevitable total clash between civilizations - and it is indeed a clash of civilizations - that of the modern world with the medieval world so embraced by the ever-emerging as dominant - extremist Islamists.

But for some reason or another, moderate Muslims prefer to sit back instead of stand up. Hence, your scenario is sooner or later, unfortunately, likely to occur, with ever-increasing likelihood owing to the appeasement of our leaders and an unwillingness to stop this thing now rather than put off the inevitable until such time it becomes more difficult and more costly.

# Posted by Richard at 09/18/2006 09:15 am - reply- forum