March 29, 2005
On "Let's Not Delude Ourselves About the Consequences of Killing Terri Schiavo"Topics: Terri Schiavo's Life Counts
- Don Hawthorne at Anchor Rising
The case of Terri Schiavo has been framed by the media as the battle between the "right to die" and pro-life groups, with the latter often referred to as "right-wing Christians." Little attention has been paid to the more than twenty major disability rights organizations firmly supporting Schiavo's right to nutrition and hydration. Terri Schindler-Schiavo, a severely disabled woman, is being starved and dehydrated to death in the name of supposed "dignity"...
...A close examination of the Schiavo case reveals not a case of difficult decisions but a basic test of this country's decency...
Our country has learned that we cannot judge people on the basis of minority status, but for some reason we have not erased our prejudice against disability...
Essentially, then, we have arrived at the point where we starve
people to death because he or she cannot communicate their experiences
to us. What is this but sheer egotism? Regardless of one's religious
beliefs, this is obviously an attempt to play God.
Not Dead Yet, an organization of persons with disabilities who oppose assisted suicide and euthanasia, maintains that the starvation and dehydration of Terri Schiavo will put the lives of thousands of severely disabled children and adults at risk...Not Dead Yet exposes important biases in the "right to die" movement, including the fact that as early as 1988, Jack Kevorkian advertised his intention of performing medical experimentation ("hitherto conducted on rats") on living children with spina bifida, at the same time harvesting their organs for reuse.
Besides being disabled, Schiavo and I have something important in common, that is, someone attempted to terminate my life by removing my endotracheal tube during resuscitation in my first hour of life. This was a quality-of-life decision: I was simply taking too long to breathe on my own, and the person who pulled the tube believed I would be severely disabled if I lived, since lack of oxygen causes cerebral palsy. (I was saved by my family doctor inserting another tube as quickly as possible.) The point of this is not that I ended up at Harvard and Schiavo did not, as some people would undoubtedly conclude. The point is that society already believes to some degree that it is acceptable to murder disabled people.
As Schiavo starves to death, we are entering a world last encountered in Nazi Europe. Prior to the genocide of Jews, Gypsies, and Poles, the Nazis engaged in the mass murder of disabled children and adults, many of whom were taken from their families under the guise of receiving treatment for their disabling conditions. The Nazis believed that killing was the highest form of treatment for disability.
...This sick twisting of medical ethics led to a sense of fulfillment of duty experienced by Nazi doctors, leading them to a conviction that they were relieving suffering. Not Dead Yet has uncovered the same perverse sense of duty in members of the Hemlock Society, now called End-of-Life Choices. (In 1997, the executive director of the Hemlock Society suggested that judicial review be used regularly "when it is necessary to hasten the death of an individual whether it be a demented parent, a suffering, severely disabled spouse or a child." This illustrates that the "right to die" movement favors the imposition of death sentences on disabled people by means of the judicial branch.)
For an overview of what "end-of-life choices" mean for Schiavo, I refer you to the Exit Protocol prepared for her in 2003 by her health care providers (available online). In the midst of her starvation, Terri will most likely be treated for "pain or discomfort" and nausea which may arise as the result of the supposedly humane process of bringing about her death. (Remember that Schiavo is not terminally ill.) She may be given morphine for respiratory distress and may experience seizures. This protocol confirms what we have learned from famines and death camps: death by starvation is a horrible death.
This apparently is what it means to have "rights" as a disabled person in America today.
JunkYardBlog has a posting on the possible consequences of Terri's death:
cross posted at BlogsForTerri
Posted by Hyscience at March 29, 2005 3:52 PM
Like Jesse Jackson, I, too, as an African-American am concerned. Germans of African descent were in danger of genocide also after the Nazia had killed 300,000 other disabled Germans, some by starvation. Read the May 1970 issue of Ebony Magazine article "How Racists Use Science to Degrade Black People" to find out how we are considered to have defective brains and to be 100,000 years behind white people in evolutionary development.
Posted by: Pearl Ware at March 30, 2005 9:04 AM
Articles Related to Terri Schiavo's Life Counts: